Before-and-after comparison
In a before-and-after comparison, you ask the same question twice, such as before and after a discussion, or at the beginning and end of a lesson. The comparison shows whether and how the class and each person have changed, and it invites reflection: What changed your mind?
about 5 to 15 minutesUpdated: 10/24/2026
What it’s for
- Learning and changes of mind become visible, for the class and for each person.
- The change itself is a strong prompt for reflection.
- Confirmation counts too: Whoever stays now knows better why.
How it runs in the room
- At the start: Everyone stands on a line, and the positions are photographed or noted.
- Then comes the input, the exercise, or the discussion.
- At the end: the same question, the same line. Who has moved?
How to do it with Lineup
How Lineup works
- You build a plan from cards on your laptop: question, slide, pairs. In class, you click from card to card.
- Up front, the projector shows the shared picture and the code for joining.
- Everyone takes part in the browser on their own device: enter the code, pick a name, go. No app, no account.
How to build it, card by card
In the editor you add one card after another: first the tile, then the type, then the settings. The words appear exactly like this in the editor.
- Action then LineWhen you revealYour question, for example at the start of the lesson.
- Teams then Inside-outside circleoptionalIn between: discussion, input, or exercise. In the template, it’s an inside-outside circle.
- Action then LineWhen you revealCompare before/afterThe same question with the same ends, compared with the first. Only available on the line.
Shortcut: the template “Debating a statement” already includes the cards shown with a picture. “Open in the editor” starts with it, and you adjust the texts.
How it runs in class
- Before Everyone answers, you reveal. Then comes discussion, input, or exercise.
- After Everyone answers again and only then sees their first answer.
- Compare After the reveal, Lineup shows how the class’s answers have changed.
Try the ready-made plan first: In the dress rehearsal, sample participants join in, and you see your controls and a phone side by side. No account, no real class.
Variations
- Statement, discussion, statement: In between, an inside-outside circle with partners who answered differently.
- Change of perspective: The same question from your own point of view and from someone else’s; the arcs show the distance.
- Self-assessment: “How confident are you about applying this yourself?” at the beginning and the end of the lesson.
Tips for the discussion
- Ask about change, not about right and wrong: “What changed your mind?”
- Ask about confirmation too: “What reassured you?”
- No ranking and no individual differences in front of everyone: The comparison talks about the class.